-
1
- Heath Herring
- "The Texas Crazy Horse"
- 28-16-0, 1 NC
-
2
- Clay Guida
- "The Carpenter"
- 38-24-0
-
3
- Roy Nelson
- "Big Country"
- 23-19-0
-
4
- Charlie Brenneman
- "The Spaniard"
- 19-8-0
-
5
- Chuck Liddell
- "The Iceman"
- 21-9-0
-
6
- Erick Silva
- "The Tiger"
- 20-11-0, 1 NC
-
7
- Jason Miller
- "Mayhem"
- 24-10-0, 1 NC
-
8
- Benson Henderson
- "Smooth"
- 30-12-0
-
9
- Miguel Torres
- 44-9-0
-
10
- Josh Koscheck
- "Kos"
- 17-11-0
-
11
- Scott Jorgensen
- "Young Guns" | 15-12-0