-
1
- Jeff Nader
- "Scary Nickname"
- 5-5-0, 1 NC
-
2
- Rick Pfeifer
- "The Ginger With the Intent to Injure"
- 5-6-0
-
3
- Luis Pena
- "Violent Bob Ross"
- 12-6-0
-
4
- Andre Fili
- "Touchy"
- 23-11-0, 1 NC
-
5
- Fernando Torrico
- "Brock Lesnar"
- Am 1-0-0
-
6
- Matthew Perry
- "The Carebear"
- 5-5-0
-
7
- Ian McCall
- "Uncle Creepy"
- 13-7-1
-
8
- John Phillips
- "The Welsh Wrecking Machine"
- 22-11-0, 1 NC
-
9
- Carla Esparza
- "The Cookie Monster"
- 19-7-0