Topic: Henderson vs. Edgar II

[POLL] Who do you think won the title bout (Henderson vs. Edgar II)?

Anonymous Mode

You are not logged in to Tapology. When browsing anonymously, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

Fatality
Fatality
  • Location: Columbus, OH, USA
  • Member Since: 2012.01.16
  • Predictions:  1,982  |  64.7%
  • Forum Posts:  476
  • Post Score: 253

08.12.2012 | 1:05 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

POLL: Scroll down to Gregory's post because he needed to steal my thunder. :(

Just curious of how most of Tapology viewed the fight.


* Edited at 08.12.2012, 2:05 AM ET *

Benson Henderson defeats Frankie Edgar via 5 Round Decision

"Smooth" Benson Henderson
Frankie "The Answer" Edgar

Henderson
Decision
Round 5

Benson Henderson Frankie Edgar

"Smooth" "The Answer"

16-2-0   Pro Record At Fight   15-2-1
Climbed to 17-2   Record After Fight   Fell to 15-3
-200 (Moderate Favorite)   Betting Odds   +170 (Slight Underdog)
Champion   Title   Challenger
United States   Nationality   United States
Glendale, Arizona   Fighting out of   Toms River, New Jersey
28 years, 8 months, 3 weeks, 5 days   Age at Fight   30 years, 9 months, 3 weeks, 5 days
154.4 lbs (70.0 kgs)   Weigh-In Result   154.6 lbs (70.1 kgs)
5'9" (175cm)   Height   5'6" (168cm)
70.0" (178cm)   Reach   68.0" (173cm)
MMA Lab   Gym   Ricardo Almeida Jiu Jitsu
Tapology Community Predictions: 1483  
.
KO/TKO
.
Submission
.
Decision
Henderson
72%
Edgar
28%

Responses

SRAOnline
SRAOnline
  • Location: Canberra, Australian Capital Territory
  • Member Since: 2012.05.25
  • Predictions:  9,853  |  60.3%
  • Forum Posts:  1,719
  • Post Score: 303

08.12.2012 | 1:07 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

Predicted Bendo, but thought Frankie edged it out.

This is Machida/Shogun I all over again.

"Pretend to be someone you're not once, and you're a liar. Do it every day, and you're a professional."

Gregory
Gregory
  • Location: Boston
  • Member Since: 2010.05.24
  • Predictions:  6,798  |  63.3%
  • Forum Posts:  18,114
  • Post Score: 243

08.12.2012 | 1:08 AM ET

Cast your vote here

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

Thumbs UP if you thought Ben Henderson won.

Thumbs DOWN if you thought Edgar won.


My guess is more will vote down with Edgar but I can handle the thumbs.

"I live, I die, I live again."

theMMAmessiah
theMMAmessiah
  • Location: Indianapolis, Indiana
  • Member Since: 2011.09.17
  • Predictions:  7,992  |  66.5%
  • Forum Posts:  8,433
  • Post Score: 72

08.12.2012 | 1:09 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

Greg just threw himself onto the down arrow sword on that one.
benjaminbrandt
benjaminbrandt
  • Member Since: 2011.01.02
  • Predictions:  18,269  |  65.6%
  • Forum Posts:  15,716
  • Post Score: 202

08.12.2012 | 1:10 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

I was leaning Edgar, but you have to BEAT the champ to get his belt. 

"I have not yet begun to defile myself. "

jaffacakehero
jaffacakehero
  • Location: Imaginationland
  • Member Since: 2010.11.25
  • Predictions:  5,066  |  62.0%
  • Forum Posts:  5,396
  • Post Score: 219

08.12.2012 | 1:13 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

I agree you do have to beat the champ...

That's why Henderson shouldn't be wearing that belt.

"If you're matched up against me, you better be prepared to give your life...because I am prepared to take it. - Conor McGregor"

Fatality
Fatality
  • Location: Columbus, OH, USA
  • Member Since: 2012.01.16
  • Predictions:  1,982  |  64.7%
  • Forum Posts:  476
  • Post Score: 253

08.12.2012 | 1:16 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  


Round 1:  10-9 Henderson
Round 2:  10-9 Edgar
Round 3:  10-10
Round 4:  10-9 Edgar*
Round 5:  10-9 Edgar
49-47 Edgar

*I thought Henderson outstruck Edgar slightly, but Edgar overcame that with the takedown and guillotine attempt

* Edited at 08.12.2012, 2:05 AM ET *

MikeLovesTacos XD
MikeLovesTacos XD
  • Location: Ontario, Canada
  • Member Since: 2011.07.14
  • Predictions:  29,276  |  59.2%
  • Forum Posts:  22,462
  • Post Score: 185

08.12.2012 | 1:33 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   wrong Submission   wrong Round 4  

People are makign a bit too much of this (Shogun/MAchida 1) all over again, this fight was as close to a draw as you can possibly get without it being a draw. Every single round Benson landed more significant strikes, overall landed more strikes. Edgar got 2 TDs, had very good control when he got them and went for 2 submission attempts compared to Bensons 1. That in no way is a robbery. 

"Is normal. Everybody go down." -- Patricky Pitbull

TinShadowcat
TinShadowcat
  • Location: Auburn, AL, USA
  • Member Since: 2012.05.30
  • Predictions:  642  |  61.7%
  • Forum Posts:  77
  • Post Score: 132

08.12.2012 | 1:43 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

Round 1:  10-9 Henderson
Round 2:  10-9 Edgar
Round 3:  10-9 Edgar
Round 4:  10-9 Edgar
Round 5:  10-9 Edgar

RESULT:  49-46 Edgar

* Edited at 08.12.2012, 1:43 AM ET *

"War Damn Eagle!"

Swickotine
Swickotine
  • Location: VERSACEFORNiA
  • Member Since: 2011.05.02
  • Predictions:  17,304  |  61.8%
  • Forum Posts:  11,851
  • Post Score: 197

08.12.2012 | 1:48 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

1 - Henderson
2 - Clearly Edgar
3 - DRAW/Slight Adv. Edgar
4 - Edgar
5- Clearly Edgar

"I'm old enough to know better, young enough to not give a ****...rather hold my head high and die, than live and duck."

p4pgoat
p4pgoat
  • Location: USA
  • Member Since: 2011.02.25
  • Predictions:  4,852  |  62.9%
  • Forum Posts:  3,908
  • Post Score: 120

08.12.2012 | 1:50 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

Round 1    10-9 Benson

Round 2    10-9 Frankie

Round 3    10-9 Benson

Round 4    10-9 Frankie

Round 5    10-9 Frankie

I love both fighters and was just cheering for a good fight. My scoring is totally unbiased on this fight. It was fricken awesome being there live as well!!!!!!!!!!!

"We are all human, it's time to prove it."

SonnensSyringe
SonnensSyringe
  • Location: Woodmere, NY
  • Member Since: 2011.03.13
  • Predictions:  78,939  |  62.7%
  • Forum Posts:  1,881
  • Post Score: 304

08.12.2012 | 1:58 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

I am a little surprised at the backlash of this decision. Personally, I don't think many people at all scored it like I did. Nonetheless, I shall go back and re-watch the fight tomorrow or sometime this week.

Round 1: 10-9 Henderson
Round 2: 10-9 Edgar
Round 3: 10-10 Draw
Round 4: 10-9 Henderson
Round 5: 10-10 Draw
Total: 49-48 Henderson.

I realize I am probably going to get down arrowed to hell for this, but if it's any consolation, I could see the fight being a draw or even swinging in favor of Edgar. The last three rounds were pretty ambiguous for me.

"You look like a 1987 John Hughes high school bully." - Swickotine

floppyanteater
floppyanteater
  • Location: Hoyt Lakes, MN
  • Member Since: 2012.04.10
  • Predictions:  6,061  |  62.2%
  • Forum Posts:  25
  • Post Score: 132

08.12.2012 | 1:59 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

Rd. 1 - Henderson 10-9
Rd. 2 - Edgar 10-9

Rd. 3 - Edgar 10-9 but I can see why some people picked Henderson

Rd. 4 - Edgar 10-9

Rd. 5 - Edgar 10-9

 

SonnensSyringe
SonnensSyringe
  • Location: Woodmere, NY
  • Member Since: 2011.03.13
  • Predictions:  78,939  |  62.7%
  • Forum Posts:  1,881
  • Post Score: 304

08.12.2012 | 2:21 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

"You look like a 1987 John Hughes high school bully." - Swickotine

Swickotine
Swickotine
  • Location: VERSACEFORNiA
  • Member Since: 2011.05.02
  • Predictions:  17,304  |  61.8%
  • Forum Posts:  11,851
  • Post Score: 197

08.12.2012 | 2:23 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

Why the **** do people use 10-10...THERE'S NO SUCH THING IN UFC. It's a 10-9 MUST...jesus why does everyone keep saying 10-10?

"I'm old enough to know better, young enough to not give a ****...rather hold my head high and die, than live and duck."

TinShadowcat
TinShadowcat
  • Location: Auburn, AL, USA
  • Member Since: 2012.05.30
  • Predictions:  642  |  61.7%
  • Forum Posts:  77
  • Post Score: 132

08.12.2012 | 2:50 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

@Swickotine Yes they can.  Where the hell'd you hear they can't score 10-10?
From www.ufc.com:  The 10-Point Must System will be the standard system of scoring a bout. Under the 10-Point Must Scoring System, 10 points must be awarded to the winner of the round and 9 points or less must be awarded to the loser, except for a rare even round, which is scored (10-10).


"War Damn Eagle!"

jaykool777
jaykool777
  • Location: Bakersfield, CA
  • Member Since: 2011.05.19
  • Predictions:  25,514  |  61.6%
  • Forum Posts:  3,654
  • Post Score: 131

08.12.2012 | 2:54 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

@ jaffacakehero - fully agree with your 1st post.

"Keep it punk rock!!!!"

Fatality
Fatality
  • Location: Columbus, OH, USA
  • Member Since: 2012.01.16
  • Predictions:  1,982  |  64.7%
  • Forum Posts:  476
  • Post Score: 253

08.12.2012 | 2:58 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  

10-10's are obviously rare but they do exist in MMA. In my initial viewing, the third round was just that close where it warranted a 10-10. I do plan to watch the match again and perhaps a third time. So, the final opinion might potentially change, but it's a draw for me in the first viewing of the bout.
jaykool777
jaykool777
  • Location: Bakersfield, CA
  • Member Since: 2011.05.19
  • Predictions:  25,514  |  61.6%
  • Forum Posts:  3,654
  • Post Score: 131

08.12.2012 | 3:11 AM ET

Prediction: wrong Edgar   wrong Decision  

Round 1 - Henderson 10-9

Round 2 - Edgar 10-9

Round 3 - Henderson 10-9

Round 4 - Edgar 10-9

Round 5 - Edgar 10-9

48-47 for Edgar.

I've watched the fight twice now, and I came up with the same score as the first time I watched the fight. The 2nd time I watched the fight, I watched on mute to make sure that I wasn't being swayed by Joe Rogan's commentary.

"Keep it punk rock!!!!"

Motizzle Sizzle
Motizzle Sizzle
  • Location: Morgantown, West Virginia
  • Member Since: 2012.08.09
  • Predictions:  7,232  |  59.8%
  • Forum Posts:  31
  • Post Score: 200

08.12.2012 | 3:20 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   wrong KO/TKO   wrong Round 4  

I said either 49-46 or 48-47 Edgar. Even though I felt that Edgar won, I don't feel that it was decisive. So, I somewhat disagree that he got "robbed", simply that it was a bad call. A lot of times in situations like this, if the challenger doesn't definitively defeat the champion, they'll give a close decision to the champ no matter if the other guy barely won. Don't agree but that's the way the cookie crumbles, I guess.
MMA4LIFE00
MMA4LIFE00
  • Member Since: 2011.12.03
  • Predictions:  14,630  |  64.5%
  • Forum Posts:  648
  • Post Score: 56

08.12.2012 | 3:24 AM ET

Prediction: correct Henderson   correct Decision  


All im going to say right now is i thought Edgar won. I'll watch it again and give scores tomorrow.


You must be signed in to reply. Sign in or register to join the discussion.

As an anonymous reader, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

  • MMA Junkie : Rory MacDonald opens up about decision to retire from MMA: 'It's not who I am anymore'
  • MMAFighting.com : Rory MacDonald tried to ignore retirement, ‘but your body and your flesh kind of cries out to you’
  • MMA Junkie : UFC 280 adds Hamdy Abdelwahab vs. Parker Porter heavyweight bout
  • MMA Junkie : Leon Edwards agrees with Dana White: Kamaru Usman trilogy next with UFC 278 title win
  • MMAFighting.com : UFC 278 Embedded, Episode 3: ‘Bringing back that animalistic behavior, that’s when that beauty comes out’
  • MMA Junkie : T.J. Dillashaw: Sean O'Malley great for MMA, but most likely Petr Yan will 'run through him' at UFC 280
  • MMA Junkie : Video: UFC 278 media day live stream
  • MMA Junkie : Yazmin Jauregui praises Iasmin Lucindo after tough UFC San Diego win: 'We're the future of the division'
  • MMAFighting.com : Coach: Jon Jones would love to face Israel Adesanya and ‘bust him up worse than he did Brandon Vera’
  • MMA Junkie : UFC 278 'Embedded,' No. 3: 'I feel like a monster right now'
  • MMA Junkie : UFC hopefuls Brandon Lewis, Daniel Marcos to square off on Dana White's Contender Series
  • MMA Weekly : UFC 278 Results: Kamaru Usman vs. Leon Edwards 2
  • MMA Junkie : Esteban Ribovics vows UFC performances will be 'even more impressive' than DWCS 50 knockout
  • UFC.com : It's Still Kamaru Usman Time
  • MMA Junkie : With UFC contract secured, Claudio Ribeiro wants to be Mike Tyson of middleweight division
  • UFC.com : Leon Edwards Finally Gets His Chance
  • MMA Junkie : Jose Johnson: Dana White moved by my story but also looked at hard work to deserve UFC contract
  • MMAFighting.com : UFC 278 commentary team set: Joe Rogan joins Daniel Cormier and Jon Anik in Salt Lake City
  • MMA Junkie : Nazim Sadykhov ready to 'cause a sh*tstorm' after DWCS 50 win – preferably starting at UFC 281
  • MMA Junkie : Hailey Cowan isn't sure what Dana White meant by 'it factor,' but she's thankful for UFC contract