Tapology Privacy Policy

Tapology Forums

Who won: Josh Thomson vs Ben Henderson?

Forum Home  |  Topic Page Help

Anonymous Mode

You are not logged in to Tapology. When browsing anonymously, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

Nomad
Nomad
  • Location: Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
  • Member Since: 2013.04.05
  • Predictions:  3,465  |  66.3%
  • Forum Posts:  5,117
  • Post Score: 181

01.25.2014 | 10:50 PM ET

Up Votes for Thomson, Down votes for Henderson.

"If I have a goal, then it is to escape from this literalism. I'll never achieve it; in the same way that I'll never manage to describe what really dwells within my character, although I keep on trying."

Responses

joe kerr
joe kerr
  • Location: Servin' you!
  • Member Since: 2011.10.08
  • Predictions:  246,976  |  68.9%
  • Forum Posts:  4,850
  • Post Score: 267

01.25.2014 | 10:53 PM ET

That looks like an easy way to get up votes. I bet Bill wishes he thought of it first.

"If the enemy rejects the ground, I would take him down by tackle. Why didn’t he [Royler] do so? May I introduce him to a good coach? His tackle was... like a girl’s one... Mr. Royler, how are you feeling?" - Kazushi Sakuraba

benjaminbrandt
benjaminbrandt
  • Member Since: 2011.01.02
  • Predictions:  18,270  |  65.6%
  • Forum Posts:  15,716
  • Post Score: 229

01.25.2014 | 10:58 PM ET


It was a close fight. 

"I have not yet begun to defile myself. "

radardarrion47
radardarrion47
  • Location: Indianapolis, In
  • Member Since: 2013.12.27
  • Predictions:  3,183  |  57.0%
  • Forum Posts:  16
  • Post Score: 106

01.25.2014 | 11:00 PM ET

My boy Henderson! Get that Belt Back!

"MMA all day !"

Nomad
Nomad
  • Location: Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
  • Member Since: 2013.04.05
  • Predictions:  3,465  |  66.3%
  • Forum Posts:  5,117
  • Post Score: 181

01.25.2014 | 11:00 PM ET

Im not worried about getting upvotes, have you seen my posts?

"If I have a goal, then it is to escape from this literalism. I'll never achieve it; in the same way that I'll never manage to describe what really dwells within my character, although I keep on trying."

NoJuice11
NoJuice11
  • Location: Maryland
  • Member Since: 2012.04.18
  • Predictions:  8,305  |  63.0%
  • Forum Posts:  1,544
  • Post Score: 208

01.25.2014 | 11:01 PM ET

It was deffinetly a close fight, I knew it would be, but I also felt like those Thomson controlled  20 minutes of that fight...but I'm not a judge so what I do I know

"Dude everyone knows Shaq got rich off playing in college"-Baseketball

Nomad
Nomad
  • Location: Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
  • Member Since: 2013.04.05
  • Predictions:  3,465  |  66.3%
  • Forum Posts:  5,117
  • Post Score: 181

01.25.2014 | 11:22 PM ET

Close fights don't excuse bad decisions, I thought.Thomson easily won rounds.1 and 2 the other three were.much close but.I think I had.it 49-46 Thomson.

"If I have a goal, then it is to escape from this literalism. I'll never achieve it; in the same way that I'll never manage to describe what really dwells within my character, although I keep on trying."

FresnoMMA
FresnoMMA
  • Location: California
  • Member Since: 2011.10.02
  • Predictions:  59,412  |  68.7%
  • Forum Posts:  7,439
  • Post Score: 204

01.25.2014 | 11:42 PM ET

I had Bendo winning a close decision. I'm not sure why there SO much controversy, but whatevss.  Henderson is going to get the title back
yossgold
yossgold
  • Location: Tel Aviv, Israel
  • Member Since: 2012.07.25
  • Predictions:  67,578  |  62.2%
  • Forum Posts:  14,550
  • Post Score: 295

01.25.2014 | 11:47 PM ET

I said it the event's thread, but since you started this one, here is is again :)

1 & 4 - Thomson
3 & 5 - Bendo

2, I think Bendo edged but would understand Thomson getting it.

Either way, people need to start learning the difference between a fight where one fighter won his rounds more decisively than the other guy won his (giving the sense of him dominating) and robbery (the word is thrown around a bit too much).

The way I see it, 1,3,4 & 5 we pretty much called the same my 90% of the people and since round 2 is debatable, it's no robbery. The reason for the outcry is usually because one fighter looked like he was winning because he won his rounds in a more dominant fashion or because everyone hates the other guy. That doesn't change the fact that he almost unanimously lost 2 rounds.

Within the current scoring system, this was a good decision, not popular, but good (as would giving Thomson the nod, due to round 2 being so close).

* Edited at 01.25.2014, 11:53 PM ET *

"Hay lohh you Mike, ay lov you Mike. Hyou say somesing like di fo me, and naw I say you ... I LOV YOU! See you som. Boy." -- Yoel Romero, UFC 205

ED209
ED209
  • Location: Ontario
  • Member Since: 2012.05.27
  • Predictions:  7,297  |  61.1%
  • Forum Posts:  3,437
  • Post Score: 213

01.25.2014 | 11:49 PM ET

I don't think it was a robbery. It was close, I thought Josh won but Bendo just really brings out my inner hater. 

"30-26 Tim Boetsch"

yossgold
yossgold
  • Location: Tel Aviv, Israel
  • Member Since: 2012.07.25
  • Predictions:  67,578  |  62.2%
  • Forum Posts:  14,550
  • Post Score: 295

01.25.2014 | 11:51 PM ET

With that I agree ... I felt that Bendo's karmic debt + Josh's heart and career story had to finally turn things around ... you wouldn't find me crying any tears if Bendo lost this one :)

"Hay lohh you Mike, ay lov you Mike. Hyou say somesing like di fo me, and naw I say you ... I LOV YOU! See you som. Boy." -- Yoel Romero, UFC 205

DietDrPepper
DietDrPepper
  • Member Since: 2011.03.05
  • Predictions:  14,982  |  63.0%
  • Forum Posts:  637
  • Post Score: 180

01.25.2014 | 11:59 PM ET

Josh 1,2,4 

Close fight sure but one judge clearly is an incompetent, I can't see how anybody saw Bendo win 4 rounds. You could make an argument that Bendo won the second, no problem, but that score was embarrassing. Bendo should be 1-3 in his last 4. I'm a fan of the guy but fair is fair. 
joe kerr
joe kerr
  • Location: Servin' you!
  • Member Since: 2011.10.08
  • Predictions:  246,976  |  68.9%
  • Forum Posts:  4,850
  • Post Score: 267

01.26.2014 | 12:06 AM ET



"If the enemy rejects the ground, I would take him down by tackle. Why didn’t he [Royler] do so? May I introduce him to a good coach? His tackle was... like a girl’s one... Mr. Royler, how are you feeling?" - Kazushi Sakuraba

morganheff
morganheff
  • Member Since: 2011.03.19
  • Predictions:  1,705  |  54.3%
  • Forum Posts:  110
  • Post Score: 162

01.26.2014 | 12:58 AM ET

Bendo hasn't finished a fight in the UFC. He consistently wins by horrible judging.

"Roy Nelson is not human. He's not human man, I've never seen anything like that... a zombie with a mullet" -Dana White, UFC185 post fight presser

amp112
amp112
  • Location: The Town
  • Member Since: 2012.10.14
  • Predictions:  37,156  |  62.2%
  • Forum Posts:  5,588
  • Post Score: 208

01.26.2014 | 1:18 AM ET

The round that was most in question for me was 4. I felt Bendo controlled the fight for almost 4 min in the clinch and with his striking, but Thomson took his back for the last 80-90 seconds of the round. So the question is what counts as more. 

I gave Bendo that round along with 3 and 5. Maybe if Thomson got a legit choke attempt, I would give him the round.

Thomson clearly won round 1 and 2. I'd even say that in Thomson's two rounds, he did more than Bendo did in the other 2 rounds I gave him. That 5th was also really close too.

Close fight, but I gave it to Bendo on the slightest of margins. So close, that I'm not gonna argue my point. Seems the point of this thread is opinion based, so that's what was going through my head when I scored the fight.

* Edited at 01.26.2014, 1:19 AM ET *

morganheff
morganheff
  • Member Since: 2011.03.19
  • Predictions:  1,705  |  54.3%
  • Forum Posts:  110
  • Post Score: 162

01.26.2014 | 1:33 AM ET

The fact that one judge called it a 49-46 for Henderson has to make you wonder if they're watching the same fight though. I had Thomson winning 1 and 2 decisively, 4th by a smaller margin and thought the 5th was very close. The only round I saw Henderson winning decisively was the 3rd.

"Roy Nelson is not human. He's not human man, I've never seen anything like that... a zombie with a mullet" -Dana White, UFC185 post fight presser

fglop
fglop
  • Member Since: 2011.01.25
  • Predictions:  1,625  |  70.0%
  • Forum Posts:  1,061
  • Post Score: 150

01.26.2014 | 2:07 AM ET

I thought 2 was a lot more questionable than you guys are giving it credit for.
amp112
amp112
  • Location: The Town
  • Member Since: 2012.10.14
  • Predictions:  37,156  |  62.2%
  • Forum Posts:  5,588
  • Post Score: 208

01.26.2014 | 2:08 AM ET

I don't have a huge problem with that in this specific fight. Look at what we're saying. All of us are giving Bendo 2 rounds and we're disagreeing on the one round. Like I said 4 to Bendo, but close. Yoss said 2 to Bendo, but close.

So theoretically, that one judge could have given Benderson 2-5. Which isn't that big of a deal. Rounds 2, 4 and 5 were very close.

I'm just making sense of it all. Bendo did not deserve 4 rounds, but when you think about it, it's not THAT bad.
zarog
zarog
  • Location: Milky Way Galaxy
  • Member Since: 2011.11.07
  • Predictions:  2,855  |  63.8%
  • Forum Posts:  4,174
  • Post Score: 241

01.26.2014 | 2:21 AM ET

Like I had said in a post in the other discussion thread, any score from 49-46 Thomson to 49-46 Henderson is defensible. Pretty much everyone agrees that Thomson won round 1 and Benson won round 3. Every other round is debatable. Personally, I thought it was a draw, but all 3 scores the judges gave were fine with me. If you take a look at the scorecards, every judge gave round 1 to Thomson and round 3 to Benson.

"Surrender??!! You think this letter on my head stands for France?" - Captain America

JustynOfOsiris
JustynOfOsiris
  • Location: Colorado
  • Member Since: 2011.04.26
  • Predictions:  4,334  |  57.2%
  • Forum Posts:  3,239
  • Post Score: 122

01.26.2014 | 2:34 AM ET

I had Thomson winning 1, 2 and 4 with 5 going either way. I without a doubt think Josh won that fight and 49 - 46 for Bendo is a god damn joke. I now know how all the people who had Bendo beating Edgar and Gil feel.

"Is reality really realistic?"

mmafan2013
mmafan2013
  • Location: N.ire
  • Member Since: 2013.11.21
  • Predictions:  106  |  69.8%
  • Forum Posts:  447
  • Post Score: -220

01.26.2014 | 3:12 AM ET

josh thomson on about retirement so he defo done :(

"Element Knows"

Forum Home  |  Topic Page Help


You must be signed in to reply. Sign in or register to join the discussion.

As an anonymous reader, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

  • Jits Magazine : Matheus Diniz Becomes Latest Champion To Leave ADCC 2024 For Craig Jones Invitational
  • MMAFighting.com : Watch William Haycox finish rare banana split submission at FCC 38
  • Middle Easy : Josh Thomson Disagrees With Dana White, Says Jon Jones Didn’t Beat The Best Heavyweight But Found Success Because Of His Wrestling
  • MMA Junkie : Ex-UFC title challenger Dominick Reyes relieved to snap skid: 'I'm not going anywhere'
  • MMA Mania : Contract Signed For Prochazka’s Next Fight
  • MMAFighting.com : RIZIN 47 results: Kyoji Horiguchi avenges loss to Sergio Pettis, Kleber Koike Erbst grabs slick heel hook
  • MMA Junkie : 5 biggest takeaways from UFC on ESPN 57: Did Jason Herzog ruin Nassourdine Imavov's main event moment?
  • Middle Easy : Exclusive: Jared Gordon Talks Upcoming Fight With Nasrat Haqparast, Paddy Pimblett vs. Bobby Green And Controversial Loss To ‘The Baddy’
  • MMA Junkie : Nassourdine Imavov: Referee made the right decision in TKO win over Jared Cannonier at UFC on ESPN 57
  • Bad Left Hook : Garcia arrested for felony vandalism
  • MMAFighting.com : Nassourdine Imavov on controversial Jared Cannonier stoppage at UFC Louisville: ‘It was the right decision’
  • MMA Junkie : Rizin 47 results: Kyoji Horiguchi outworks Sergio Pettis, Erbst taps Archuleta
  • Bad Left Hook : Pacquiao vs Suzuki exhibition set for July 28
  • Bad Left Hook : Manny Pacquiao vs Chihiro Suzuki exhibition set for July 28
  • MMA Mania : ‘F—k You!’
  • MMAFighting.com : Dana White reveals shocking Howie Mandel podcast walkout was planned
  • Middle Easy : Ryan Garcia Arrested At Beverly Hills Hotel For Felony Vandalism With Reportedly Over $15K In Damages
  • MMA Junkie : UFC signs Rizin bantamweight champion Kai Asakura
  • MMAFighting.com : Raul Rosas Jr. reveals conversation with Ricky Turcios after choking him out at UFC Louisville
  • MMA Junkie : Savannah Marshall's successful pro debut sets up MMA rematch with boxing rival Claressa Shields