Ajax loader

Tapology Forums

Would we see better or worse decisions if MMA wasn't scored in rounds?

Anonymous Mode

You are not logged in to Tapology. When browsing anonymously, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

ImperatorFishrat
ImperatorFishrat
  • Member Since: 2017.09.16
  • Predictions:  6,423  |  63.1%
  • Forum Posts:  10,401
  • Post Score: 194

02.19.2019 | 3:49 AM ET

I've been thinking about this a bit lately. What if instead of scoring fights round by round, each fighter was given a score from 7-10 for the entire fight?

I get that we have contingency plans in place already with 10-8's ( and soon to be 10-7's in most areas) but ultimately these don't work as intended, as ultimately MMA is about damage. A fighter might get controlled completely one round, receive a ten eight, come back and put a good solid beating on their opponent for the next two, not quite earn a 10-8 and still wind up drawing. Not much fair or realistic about that--especially if their opponent is about to go out in the closing seconds of the fight.

Now, a score of 7-10 for an entire fight would put a lot of control in the hands of the judges, but that's a damp squib anyways. They already have all the power. Wouldn't the removal of round by round scoring force the judges to think harder about who was most dominant, who looked most likely to win at the end of the fight, and most importantly who damaged who the most overall?

I don't know. What do you think?

* Edited at 02.19.2019, 3:50 AM ET *

"A forest is not a field of trees."

Responses

Zulizani
Zulizani
  • Member Since: 2017.12.12
  • Predictions:  1,900  |  61.9%
  • Forum Posts:  623
  • Post Score: 212

02.19.2019 | 4:29 AM ET

Like all things MMA, it's still evolving.  When I watch a fight I generally score it by 2 or 3 different scoring methodologies. (10 point must, pride rules & schoolyard) This is why I get confused when I see being being sad that Kongo won UD against Minakov. I mean, even if you a wrestling buff and think a TD's are worth like 20 head strikes even though he didn't pass or threaten a sub (he pretended too) and think it was bad judging, you have to agree that by pride rules or schoolyard, Kongo clearly won the fight.  I personally had it 30-27 Kongo.  I think finding a balance between scoring the grappling and the striking means the current system has the most potential to be "correct" and will likely stay around for a long time no matter how much I don't like it.

The only way to be sure is to keep them locked in the cage until there is a clear result.  Sounds good in theory but in practice MVP vs Daley goes for 14 hours and 56000 mma fans commit suicide.  Better the devil you know is what I'm saying, I guess. I dunno.

"You're all my children, I'll discipline you how I feel" Massabruce

tepid55
tepid55
  • Location: Texas
  • Member Since: 2018.12.17
  • Predictions:  6,171  |  71.5%
  • Forum Posts:  741
  • Post Score: 173

02.19.2019 | 10:57 AM ET

I think there would be better decisions if fights were scored as a whole, instead of round-by-round.
razer057
razer057
  • Location: Canada
  • Member Since: 2018.07.14
  • Predictions:  5,569  |  71.5%
  • Forum Posts:  14
  • Post Score: 164

02.19.2019 | 1:03 PM ET

If I'm not mistaken, One Championship professes to score their MMA fights as a whole, not round by round.

"Become like water my friend."

MassaBruce
MassaBruce
  • Member Since: 2016.03.07
  • Predictions:  24,860  |  66.6%
  • Forum Posts:  6,946
  • Post Score: 53

02.19.2019 | 1:32 PM ET

I agree a fight should be judged as a whole. 95% of the criteria should be based on damage. The other 5% should be about aggressiveness/willingness to engage & control. 

But if its not judged as a whole, then simply have the Round winner earning a point while the Round loser gets nothing. Super close round? Neither get a point. Judging should be open to the public like in Glory. Meaning judges HAVE to submit their scores after every round. 


I see absolutely NO reason for adding an independent-variable, people's math skills, to judging a fight. 

Also, there should be UNLIMITED use of instant-replay. Eye-poke? Lets take a look. low-blow? Lets take a look. Shot landed to the back of the head? Lets take a look. Overeem felt a tap? Lets take a look. 

"A MMA fighter died? Tap doesn't care. Somebody uses "harsh language" OMG! Stop pretending to have a conscious. This site is about violence. Can't you see that!?"

tepid55
tepid55
  • Location: Texas
  • Member Since: 2018.12.17
  • Predictions:  6,171  |  71.5%
  • Forum Posts:  741
  • Post Score: 173

02.19.2019 | 4:10 PM ET

Even though ONE Championship has 3 5-minute round, and 5 5-minute round fights, the fights are judged as a whole.


You must be signed in to reply. Sign in or register to join the discussion.

As an anonymous reader, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.

  • MMAFighting.com : Kelvin Gastelum vs. Jack Hermansson agreed for UFC Fight Island on July 18
  • MMAFighting.com : Carla Esparza faces Marina Rodriguez in July after inking new four-fight deal with UFC
  • MMAFighting.com : Dana White confident he’ll eventually ‘figure it out’ with Jon Jones despite current tension
  • MMA Weekly : UFC 250: Amanda Nunes vs. Felicia Spencer – Inside the Octagon Preview
  • MMAFighting.com : UFC full fight video: Rashad Evans takes light heavyweight title from Forrest Griffin
  • MMAFighting.com : UFC veteran Takeya Mizugaki announces retirement
  • MMA Weekly : Jon Jones: ‘It’s going to take America as a whole to save our country’
  • MMA Weekly : UFC 1: The life and times of Gerard Gordeau
  • MMAFighting.com : Tim Sylvia: UFC refusing to provide financial aid for arm injury suffered at UFC 48
  • UFC.com : Significant Stats: UFC 250
  • MMAFighting.com : Juan Adams addresses racial injustice in open letter: ‘I was viewed an ‘adult level threat’ since I was 12 years old’
  • MMA Weekly : Watch Sean O’Malley make quick work of Jose Quinonez (UFC 250 Free Fight)
  • UFC.com : UFC Raises Record $370,500 During All-In Challenge
  • MMAFighting.com : UFC on ESPN 9 averages just over 1 million viewers with SpaceX launch earning biggest ratings
  • MMAFighting.com : Marlon Moraes calls for Dominick Cruz next: ‘I don’t give a f**k about the rankings, I want to fight him’
  • MMAFighting.com : The A-Side Live Chat: UFC 250 preview, Amanda Nunes vs. Felicia Spencer, Jon Jones relinquishing UFC title, more
  • UFC.com : It’s Entertain or Bust for Alonzo Menifield
  • MMA Weekly : UFC 250 Embedded: Fighters arrive to an eerily quiet Las Vegas
  • UFC.com : Aljamain Sterling Ready for ‘Race to The Throne’
  • UFC.com : Ed Herman’s "Short Fuse" Used For Motivation On TUF