Topic: Edgar vs. Maynard III
Was Replacing EDGAR vs MAYNARD with RAMPAGE vs HAMIL the right thing to do?
Anonymous Mode
You are not logged in to Tapology. When browsing anonymously, profanities and images are automatically removed from the forum.
-
- LiLRASKALG
-
- Location: EAST SAN DIEGO, KILLAFORNIA
- Member Since: 2011.04.25
-
Predictions:
3,613
|
59.2%
-
Forum Posts:
373
- Post Score: 86
WOW! Cant believe maynard and edgar pulled out their fight. i woulda replaced this fight with the pettis/guida which is planned just a week after ufc130. These fighter pulling out their fight was very disappointing but having RAMPAGEvs HAMIL a main event was even more disappointing. I mean i believe that the Rampage/Hamil fight would end in fireworks but theres gotta be another fight they coulda replaced a championship bout with. Like Maybe making BOTH the RAMPAGE/HAMIL and the MIR/NELSON fight a Number One Contender match? Or maybe adding that pettis fight to the card. THATS JUST MY POINT OF VIEW. Whats yours?
-
- Gregory
-
- Location: Boston
- Member Since: 2010.05.24
-
Predictions:
6,817
|
63.3%
-
Forum Posts:
18,561
- Post Score: 275
Cool avatar, first of all.
Losing the Edgar/Maynard fight is definitely disappointing. I think the UFC has actually been fairly lucky with main event injuries in the past couple of years. For this one, on 3 weeks notice there really isn't a lot of things that the UFC can do. Most of their top fighters are already scheduled for one thing or another.
Situations like this suck, but it's just the way it goes in this sport sometimes.
-
- thiagosilva9794
-
- Location: Ireland.
- Member Since: 2010.11.25
-
Predictions:
5,113
|
60.4%
-
Forum Posts:
11,315
- Post Score: 142
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
It sucks to not have the main event but i dont think it puts too much of a downer on the card all it does is put Alves vs Story on the main card which isnt all bad ... Still a stacked card.
-
- Kalibo
-
- Location: PA
- Member Since: 2011.03.27
-
Predictions:
33,130
|
62.8%
-
Forum Posts:
16,800
- Post Score: 185
I agree with you @Lilras.. I would have much rather seen them add the Pettis fight to that card. @Greogry.. there was a year where they were plagued with injuries.. I think it was '09. '10 was a great year, but '09 was ridden with injuries. Oh well, if there isn't anything else done with the card, i will not purchase it. I'll wait to see the reply a month later.
-
- minotauro11
-
- Location: St. Louis
- Member Since: 2011.01.06
-
Predictions:
2,483
|
66.5%
-
Forum Posts:
4,493
- Post Score: 148
Yeah I wish Rampage was fighting a better/more exciting opponent, but there really isn't anything better they could have done with the card IMO. I wish they brought up a fight from 131 to 130's main card (not necessarily a new main event), but ehh, this stuff happens I guess.
-
- bklettke
-
- Location: USA
- Member Since: 2010.11.02
-
Predictions:
2,109
|
64.7%
-
Forum Posts:
1,761
- Post Score: 117
Prediction:
Edgar | Submission | Round 4
Moving fights like Pettis/Guida or from another PPV doesn't happen very often. These guys are stuck in the rhythm of their training camp and have that camp tailored to peak for a certain date, not to mention they could have minor injuries that wouldn't heal in this timeframe. It's just too iffy of a situation. I will absolutely by the card for one reason, and thats when there aren't enough high profile fights or people aren't interested becuase there is no title fight, it seems those cards are the best.
-
- Kalibo
-
- Location: PA
- Member Since: 2011.03.27
-
Predictions:
33,130
|
62.8%
-
Forum Posts:
16,800
- Post Score: 185
If anyone watched the TUF episode.. did you notice they are STILL advertising the damn fight? FAIL!
-
- LoneRonin
-
- Location: Fresno, California
- Member Since: 2011.01.19
-
Predictions:
3,222
|
62.3%
-
Forum Posts:
1,171
- Post Score: 104
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
i think its a pretty weak replacement for the Edgar/Maynard fight and I wasn't even looking forward to that fight. I am glad this happened though cause Im not going to be able to watch it that weekend anyway. I do want to see the Mir, Alves, and Stann, fights though
-
- Elkisland
-
- Location: Michigan
- Member Since: 2010.11.10
-
Predictions:
213
|
64.8%
-
Forum Posts:
499
- Post Score: 132
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
Not much could have been done I guess. But IMO Mir vs Nelson seems more like a main event.
-
- wolfmanhowl
Prediction:
Maynard | KO/TKO | Round 2
quinton " rampage" jackson is a known name and quality fighter so he get top billing with hamill. mir has alot of haters, (not one of them) and nelson is really known to the casual fan b/c of his belly.
-
- Jalm
-
- Location: N.E.P.A
- Member Since: 2011.03.25
-
Predictions:
1,064
|
58.6%
-
Forum Posts:
203
- Post Score: 155
I cant complain , Hamill is my favorite LHW actually my fav. fighter , like gregory says though on such short notice there was not much they could do .
-
- themysticalninja
-
- Location: Milton Keynes
- Member Since: 2011.04.29
-
Predictions:
1,219
|
59.5%
-
Forum Posts:
1,725
- Post Score: 123
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
It was the only thing they could do really. But that dosen't mean I have to like it and I'm sorry to sound like a hater but it's a weak main event. Hamill does not scream "main card attraction" and I can't help but feel the fight is not going to be that exciting.
If it's a back and forth affair, then I'll be glad to be wrong, but as of this moment, consider me not excited.
-
- jaffacakehero
-
- Location: Imaginationland
- Member Since: 2010.11.25
-
Predictions:
5,066
|
62.0%
-
Forum Posts:
5,396
- Post Score: 240
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
@babaywads i dont hate frank! :) haha.....
-
- kallousklown
-
- Location: san jose, california
- Member Since: 2011.01.01
-
Predictions:
24,203
|
62.6%
-
Forum Posts:
10,967
- Post Score: 177
Prediction:
Edgar | Decision
i think nelsonns gut is awesome but i dont hate mir. i like watching him fight, well except the cro cop fight.
